Comic Reviews: Nightwing Rebirth and Civil War II!



This week Dick Grayson is BACK as Nightwing, and a Marvel hero falls in Civil War III!

Nightwing-Rebirth-1Nightwing Rebirth #1 (DC Comics)

At long last, Dick Grayson is back as Nightwing. After two years (give or take) as a secret agent, the first Robin is back in his Nightwing guise, and even rocking the classic blue and black uniform. Of the second wave of DC Rebirth titles, Nightwing Rebirth was easily my most anticipated book, and now that the Tim Seeley and Yanick Paquette issue has been released, does it live up to the hype?

Kind of.

Nightwing Rebirth is a “putting the toys back” issue in many ways. While I haven’t read much of Grayson, this Rebirth issue for Dick Grayson does an okay job of explaining his new status quo, and his reasoning for getting back into the identity that made him famous. But even though I was able to follow along with this series without reading much of the previous run, I’ll admit that there were a few times where I could’ve used a little more in-depth explanation of the events that Tim Seeley glosses over in this issue, especially with the Court of Owls’ recent plot involving Damian Wayne.

Despite this, Tim Seeley’s script is pretty great. While it’s very light on plot and action, Seeley does a great job of getting into Dick Grayson’s headspace. It’s hard to think of another major comic book character that’s had more changes in the last twenty years than Dick Grayson. He’s been Robin, his own solo character, Batman, a secret agent, and now back to being Nightwing again. It’s enough to make you wonder how Dick Grayson can keep things straight, but Seeley uses these experiences to strengthen his return as Nightwing, not hinder them.

It’s always great to see Yanick Paquette’s art, and Nightwing Rebirth is no exception. Everything you love and expect to see from Paquette is here, but I was a little disappointed to see that there weren’t any crazy layouts that the artist is known for. Perhaps he didn’t have the time to make them. Regardless, Paquette’s art is still great, and compliments Seeley’s script perfectly.
Despite the fact that this issue was a little slower than I was expecting, it is great to see Dick Grayson back as Nightwing. I was never the biggest fan of the idea of making him a secret agent; so seeing him back in a costume again was a lot of fun, and has me pretty excited to jump into his new series.



Civil War II #3 (of 8) (Marvel Comics)Civil_War_II_Vol_1_3_Textless


Well, we’re here at another “major event” in a Marvel miniseries. The Marvel hype train has been in full force for this issue, with a huge media push and even permission to sell the book at midnight for retailers who deem the issue worthy of such an event. With so much hype around the latest installment of Brian Michael Bendis and David Marquez’s miniseries, it’s gotta be impossible for the end product to live up to the hype around it. Featuring the death of a “major Marvel character”, will this issue of Civil War II even make a blip on comic fans’ radar? Or will it be met with just another “shrug” after readers have forked over their $5?

Well, that’s tough to say, cause the death in question is both interesting and a complete head scratcher. I’m going to spoil it, cause there’s no way to talk about it without doing so, so if you don’t want to know the big death, TURN BACK NOW.

Still here? Okay then, it’s the Hulk. Well, technically it’s Bruce Banner, but you get the idea. I’ll admit to rolling my eyes at first when I flipped through this issue, but upon reading it, I have to admit that like with all the other issues of Civil War II, this issue is way more entertaining than it has any right to be. Bendis centers the entire issue on Banner’s death. Bouncing between Banner’s final moments and the trial of his killer, Hawkeye, Civil War II #3 is a pretty taut and entertaining issue, even if we all know that there’s no way Banner stays dead for longer than a few months.

But at the same time, there’s no way this death should work. Marvel has repeatedly stated in multiple comics that the Hulk wouldn’t allow Banner to be killed, he’d just change right before Banner would die, thereby preventing harm to him. Of course, there’s a loophole right now, as Banner’s gamma cells are currently dormant, preventing him from turning into the Hulk. But if that’s the case, why are the heroes so worried about him hulking out again? Because of Ulyssess’ visions? Is Captain Marvel’s side THAT on board with this kid that they’d believe him over someone they’ve known for years? It all seems like Bendis is making things too convenient for the story to work, and while it serves this story fine right now, I can’t imagine these events and feelings will carry into the character’s solo books. Plus trying to make this tie into current events in the world seems very forced, and just, well, wrong, like when an older relative wants to talk about current events and doesn’t completely understand them. I can see where Bendis was trying to go, but the end result is both eye-rolling and cringe-inducing.

On the art side of things, David Marquez gets an assist from Olivier Coipel for a few pages, and while it’s noticeable, there’s a reason for that. Both artists really do a great job of presenting this “huge event” in the Marvel universe, but Marquez gets the biggest showpiece. Not only does he simply have more pages that he gets to draw, but his way of showing the emotional reactions from our heroes when Banner is killed shows off how well Marquez is at emotional beats.
So yes, Civil War II features the death of a character that in no way will stay dead (and shouldn’t have died in the first place). The more I think about it, the less I like it, and it feels like a misguided attempt at trying to present current events of the real world in the Marvel one. But at the very least, I’m still thinking about it after reading it. That has to count for something, right?

Jonwahizzle is a comic book slinger for Jetpack Comics Find him on PSN (Jonwahizzle), follow him on twitter and check out his blog, The Collective: Examples of Nerdery for more!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.